The goals/aspirations for which the Croix de Fer would be less than wholly suitable for are :-
- La Marmotte
- 7x 200km LEJOG - Land's End to John O'Groats in 7 days, each a 200km audax
- Super Randonneur Series and/or Randonneur Round The Year
- Paris-Brest-Paris and/or London-Edinburgh-London
- Specialised Roubaix Sport
- Currently the leading contender as it seems to hit most of the boxes without having any obvious drawbacks.
- Whyte Wessex One
- Not wild about the colour, but could live with it! However at £1999 it does seem overpriced compared to the competition, especially as it comes with Apex 1 whilst they seem to be about the Shimano 105 level. If it was more like ≤£1600 and/or came with Rival 1 then might be a serious contender.
- Trek Domane SL5 Disc
- It was actually a discussion on this bike over on YACF that attracted my interest in this particular market segment, did rather like the description that it was so comfortable that it almost felt like cheating! :-o However the press-fit bottom bracket doesn't seem to have been trouble free for at least of the purchasers, so I'm a bit wary of it in that regard.
- Giant Defy Advanced 2
- Perhaps less comfortable than either the Roubaix or the Domane, but also much cheaper! And the money saved could be used, say, for some more aero wheels so it might end up faster except on the roughest roads? Alas the press-fit bottom bracket marks this one down too.
- Ribble CGR Ti
- To be honest I'm not 100% certain this is a real contender, other than for the fact it's made out of titanium!
- Ribble Endurance SL Disc
- Certainly has the advantage of a good price, to the point where I could be tempted to spend £ more and get the Ultegra equipped one! The custom colours option could be a little tempting too, however actually how good a bike is it? Not really willing to splurge that much on a bike that I can't ride beforehand.
I don't have enough money realistically for any of the above options at the moment, however projections say I should be able to make a purchase of whichever one I settle on towards the end of the current financial year.
The alternative to all of the above would probably be to get something like a Planet X Pro Carbon for £899, and then use the money left over plus extra saving along the way to purchase something like a Bacchetta Corsa A70 in a few years time. The Pro Carbon would be fine for anything up to 200km I'd hope, and then I could use the recumbent for anything longer that I was planning on doing later for which it would likely be better overall than any of the bikes listed above.